The Best Ice Cream & Dessert in Prosper, TX

The Sweet Scene in Prosper

Prosper has grown quickly, and its dessert options have kept pace — from homemade ice cream churned fresh every morning to gourmet cookies with a rotating weekly lineup. Whether you are looking for a post-dinner treat on Preston Road or a weekend outing with the kids, this guide covers the real spots worth knowing about.

Homemade Ice Cream and Frozen Custard

If a true scoop-shop experience is what you are after, Prosper now has two distinct destinations that take their craft seriously.

Handel’s Homemade Ice Cream on West Frontier Parkway is one of the newer additions to the Prosper dining scene. Every batch is made fresh daily in-store, and the menu runs well over 100 flavors at any given time, covering everything from classic vanilla to creative seasonal picks. It is the kind of place where you might need a few minutes to decide.

Andy’s Frozen Custard at 1151 E First St brings a concept that has been around since 1986 to Prosper. Frozen custard is a different animal from standard soft-serve — denser, richer, and made with a higher egg-yolk content. Andy’s leans into that with a menu that spans simple cones, sundaes, and concretes, plus seasonal offerings like a Pumpkin Pie Concrete and a Strawberry Shortcake Sundae. If you have never tried a concrete, this is the place to start.

Bubble Tea, Ice Cream, and Something Different

The Creamery Stone & Boba rounds out the ice cream category with a format that is a little harder to categorize in the best way. The shop combines bubble tea, ice cream, donuts, cakes, and pastries under one roof. Regular visitors single out the brownie batter ice cream as a standout flavor. The Creamery does not have a standalone website that can be confirmed, so checking Google Maps or Yelp for current hours before you go is a good idea.

Cupcakes, Cookies, and Gourmet Baked Goods

Prosper’s stretch of Preston Road has become a reliable corridor for dessert-focused spots, and several of them specialize in cookies and cupcakes done at a high level.

Smallcakes Prosper at 1101 S Preston Rd makes gourmet cupcakes, cookies, and small-batch ice cream fresh every day. Their “Smash” creation has developed a following, and the combination of baked goods and in-house ice cream makes it a solid stop if you want options without driving to two places.

Crumbl operates on a rotating weekly menu that resets every Monday, which means the cookies available this week — whether that is a chocolate chip, a mini pie, or something more unexpected — will be different next week. It has become a local ritual for a lot of Prosper families to check what dropped on Monday morning. The format is well-suited to picking up a box for a gathering or as a gift.

Tiff’s Treats at 1070 S. Preston Road is best known for warm, delivered cookies, but the in-store experience at the Prosper location goes further than most people expect. There is a full ice cream menu available by the scoop or pint, and two items — the Tiffblitz frozen ice cream dessert and the Tiffiwich ice cream sandwich — are only available when you walk in. Those two alone make a visit worth planning.

Bakery and Café

85°C Bakery Café opened its Prosper location in spring 2026 near the intersection of U.S. 380 and Gee Road. The Taiwanese-founded chain brings a broad menu of cakes, pastries, and breads, along with drinks including their well-known sea-salt coffee. It sits in a slightly different category from the dessert-first spots above, but if you are looking for a pastry and a coffee in the morning or an afternoon treat, 85°C Bakery Café fills a gap that Prosper did not have before.

Frequently Asked Questions

Where can I get homemade ice cream in Prosper, TX?

Handel’s Homemade Ice Cream at 201 W Frontier Pkwy makes every batch fresh daily with over 100 flavors available. Andy’s Frozen Custard on E First St is another strong option, specializing in frozen custard rather than traditional ice cream.

Does Prosper have a Crumbl Cookies location?

Yes. Crumbl has a Prosper location with a rotating menu that changes every Monday, offering cookies, mini pies, cakes, and specialty flavors on a weekly cycle.

What dessert spots are on Preston Road in Prosper?

Several dessert-focused businesses operate along or near Preston Road, including Smallcakes Prosper, Crumbl, and Tiff’s Treats. All three are close enough to combine into one outing if you are in the area.

Are there any dessert spots in Prosper with bubble tea?

The Creamery Stone & Boba offers bubble tea alongside ice cream, donuts, cakes, and pastries. Since hours can vary, checking Google Maps or Yelp before visiting is recommended.